Joey Buttafuoco: The Story Behind the Scandal That Rocked America

Joey Buttafuoco was once a name that everyone seemed to know. His life took a sudden and unexpected turn in the 1990s when he became involved in one of the most infamous scandals in American history. Today, more than two decades later, Buttafuoco’s story remains one that captures both curiosity and fascination. His name will forever be linked to the media frenzy surrounding his affair, a young lover, and a tragic shooting. But what happened to Joey Buttafuoco after all the media attention faded?

This is the story of Joey Buttafuoco: a man who went from being an ordinary Long Island auto body shop owner to a tabloid celebrity.

A Quiet Life Before the Scandal

Before the scandal took hold of his life, Joey Buttafuoco was an unassuming auto repair shop owner living in the suburbs of Long Island, New York. He had a wife, Mary Jo Buttafuoco, and together, they had built a relatively normal life. Buttafuoco was known for his charming personality and was a regular presence in his local community. His auto body repair shop, located in the small town of Massapequa, was a typical business that catered to customers needing car repairs.

But his quiet life would soon come to a screeching halt, all because of one young woman: Amy Fisher.

The Affair with Amy Fisher

In the early 1990s, Joey Buttafuoco became involved in a controversial affair with a teenage girl named Amy Fisher. Fisher, who was just 16 at the time, had visited Buttafuoco’s auto shop with a car that needed repair. What began as a professional relationship quickly turned personal. The affair between the 36-year-old Buttafuoco and the young Fisher became an open secret in the local community.

Soon, the affair was no longer a hidden part of their lives. Amy Fisher, who had become deeply infatuated with Buttafuoco, would later claim that he promised to leave his wife for her. But as time passed, it became clear that Buttafuoco was not ready to make that commitment. Fisher’s obsession grew, and she became increasingly desperate to get his attention.

The Tragic Shooting

The situation took a tragic turn in May of 1992. After learning that Buttafuoco had no intention of leaving his wife for her, Amy Fisher decided to take matters into her own hands. She showed up at the Buttafuoco home one afternoon, armed with a handgun. Fisher knocked on the door of the Buttafuoco house and, after a brief conversation with Mary Jo Buttafuoco, shot her in the face at close range.

The shooting left Mary Jo Buttafuoco severely injured, but she survived the attack. However, the incident was just the beginning of a media storm that would forever change the lives of everyone involved.

The Media Frenzy

The shooting quickly became a national sensation. The media pounced on the story, and the names Joey Buttafuoco, Amy Fisher, and Mary Jo Buttafuoco were soon splashed across newspapers and tabloids. Amy Fisher, the teenage “Long Island Lolita,” became a household name, and Buttafuoco’s affair was laid bare for the entire world to see. For a time, it seemed like everyone had an opinion on the scandal, and the public was fascinated by the drama unfolding before them.

Joey Buttafuoco found himself thrust into the spotlight. The scandal was now about more than just a shooting—it became a symbol of everything from betrayal to obsession. It seemed as though no one could get enough of the sordid details of the affair, and Buttafuoco was often portrayed as a villain in the media.

The Legal Aftermath

In the wake of the shooting, Amy Fisher was arrested and charged with attempted murder. She was eventually convicted and sentenced to 5 to 15 years in prison. Buttafuoco, for his part, was also brought into the legal proceedings. Though he wasn’t charged with any criminal activity related to the shooting, he did face legal challenges as a result of the affair.

In the years that followed, Buttafuoco’s reputation was severely damaged. While his wife, Mary Jo, was able to recover physically from the shooting, their marriage could never return to normal. Buttafuoco faced public backlash, and his once-thriving auto repair shop struggled as a result of his tarnished image. His personal life seemed to unravel, and many believed that the scandal would define him forever.

The Aftermath and What Happened to Joey Buttafuoco

So, what happened to Joey Buttafuoco after the scandal faded from the media’s spotlight? In the years following the shooting and the media frenzy, Buttafuoco attempted to move on with his life. His marriage to Mary Jo eventually ended in divorce, though the two did maintain a somewhat amicable relationship in the years that followed. Joey Buttafuoco also moved on with his career and tried to rebuild his life away from the media circus.

Buttafuoco did attempt to capitalize on his newfound fame. In the mid-1990s, he appeared in a series of television interviews and even became a reality TV personality. His fame, however, was fleeting, and he was soon forgotten by many. Buttafuoco’s attempts to turn the scandal into something that could sustain his public career didn’t quite pan out as hoped.

He later opened a few businesses and even made occasional appearances on talk shows and news outlets. However, his life was far from the glamorous celebrity life many had imagined. Buttafuoco found himself living in relative obscurity, far from the public eye that had once scrutinized his every move.

A New Life and Redemption

In the years since the scandal, Joey Buttafuoco has maintained a much quieter life. He has largely stayed out of the public spotlight, though he occasionally resurfaces for interviews or speaking engagements. His focus has shifted away from his previous controversies, and today, he is living a much less dramatic life.

Despite the scandal, Buttafuoco has shown a desire for redemption. He has spoken openly about his past mistakes and has expressed regret over his actions. Buttafuoco has worked to distance himself from the media circus that once defined his life. In interviews, he has shared that he hopes to be remembered not for the scandal, but for the lessons he learned from his mistakes.

Conclusion

Joey Buttafuoco’s life was forever changed by a scandal that no one could have predicted. From a simple auto body shop owner to a tabloid sensation, Buttafuoco’s name became synonymous with one of the most talked-about scandals in American history. However, as time has passed, Buttafuoco has tried to rebuild his life away from the media spotlight. While his past will always be a part of him, Joey Buttafuoco continues to move forward, hoping that his story can be one of redemption.

For many, the story of Joey Buttafuoco is a reminder of the impact of media sensationalism, and how a person’s life can be turned upside down by a single mistake. It is a tale of scandal, obsession, and the consequences of public scrutiny. But for Joey Buttafuoco, it is also a story of survival and the quest for redemption after a lifetime of scandal.

Marilyn Lovell: The Untold Story of Apollo 13’s Real Hero