“48 Hours” Episode on Danni Houchins’ Death Uncovers Truth After 24 Years

On September 21, 1996, the small town of Belgrade, Montana, was shaken by the tragic death of 15-year-old Danielle “Danni” Houchins. Found face down in a swampy area near the Gallatin River, her death was initially shrouded in mystery, with authorities suggesting it might have been an accident. For over two decades, her family refused to accept this explanation, believing something far more sinister had happened. The CBS “48 Hours” episode titled “It’s About Danni,” aired on February 8, 2025, dives deep into this heartbreaking case, revealing the chilling truth that emerged after 24 years of relentless pursuit for justice. Reported by veteran correspondent Peter Van Sant, the episode uncovers a story of loss, determination, and groundbreaking forensic advancements that finally brought closure to a grieving family.

A Day That Changed Everything

Danni Houchins was a vibrant, outdoorsy teenager who loved fishing, hiking, and mountain climbing. On that fateful September morning in 1996, she had a minor argument with her family, as many teenagers do. Needing space, she grabbed the keys to her Chevy pickup truck and drove to the Cameron Bridge Fishing Access, a peaceful spot along the Gallatin River she often visited. At just 15, Danni was a proud driver, having earned her license in Montana, where the legal driving age was lower at the time. Her sister, Stephanie Mollet, later explained to “48 Hours” that Danni sought out the river for its tranquility, a place to clear her mind.

When Danni didn’t return home by the afternoon, her mother grew worried and set out to find her. She discovered Danni’s truck parked at the fishing access, unlocked, with her keys and water bottle left on a nearby path. There was no sign of Danni. The Gallatin County Sheriff’s Office was called, but darkness forced them to pause their search. Unwilling to wait, two family friends, familiar with the area’s marshy terrain, continued looking. Their persistence led to a devastating discovery: Danni’s body, face down in a swampy area under a willow tree, far from the path.

A Death Shrouded in Mystery

Initially, the coroner’s report concluded that Danni had drowned, and her death was labeled “undetermined.” Authorities suggested she might have tripped and fallen into the water, a theory that baffled her family. Stephanie Mollet, who was 12 at the time, found this explanation absurd. Danni was an experienced outdoorswoman, confident in rugged environments. The idea that she accidentally drowned seemed implausible. Rumors swirled in the tight-knit community, with some whispering it could have been murder, sparking fear and uncertainty.

What the family didn’t know at the time was that the coroner’s report held critical clues. Danni’s autopsy revealed bruises on her body, including the back of her neck, signs of vaginal injuries, and semen in her underwear. These findings pointed to a violent assault, but in 1996, the sheriff’s office, led by Sheriff Bill Slaughter, withheld these details to protect the investigation. Deputy Keith Farquhar, a young patrolman at the time, told “48 Hours” that it was common to keep such information confidential while pursuing suspects, including those close to Danni. Despite these efforts, no suspects were named, and the case went cold.

A Sister’s Promise

Stephanie Mollet, Danni’s younger sister, never gave up hope of finding answers. “I promised my sister, I’m coming for you, Danni,” she told Peter Van Sant in the “48 Hours” episode. Her determination became the driving force behind a decades-long quest for justice. As years passed, Stephanie grew into adulthood, but her resolve only strengthened. The official narrative of an accidental death never sat right with her or her family, who suspected foul play from the start.

In 2019, the Gallatin County Sheriff’s Office reopened Danni’s case, spurred by advancements in DNA technology and a renewed commitment to solving cold cases. Detective Sergeant Matt Boxmeyer took a personal interest in the Houchins family, recognizing they had been given little information in 1996. He shared with “48 Hours” that the family had been told Danni likely fell and drowned, a conclusion that didn’t align with the evidence. Boxmeyer, along with retired investigator Tom Elfmont, began re-examining the case, starting with preserved evidence from Danni’s truck and clothing.

Breakthroughs in DNA Technology

The turning point came in 2020 when Stephanie Mollet connected with the new investigative team. She demanded to see the autopsy report, which revealed the harrowing details of Danni’s death: bruises, signs of sexual assault, and evidence of a struggle. “Someone had held her head down forcefully,” Stephanie recounted to “48 Hours.” “She had fought and scratched.” This confirmed her worst fears—Danni had been raped and murdered.

Investigators turned to cutting-edge DNA analysis. Elfmont focused on a partial DNA profile from semen found on Danni’s underwear, but initial tests through the FBI’s DNA database yielded no matches. Then, they analyzed four rootless hairs found on Danni’s body, which were once considered nearly impossible to extract DNA from. Using state-of-the-art techniques at a private lab, they developed a full suspect DNA profile. An investigative genetic genealogist traced this profile through family trees, leading to a name in May 2024: Paul Nathaniel Hutchinson.

The Suspect and a Tragic End

Paul Hutchinson, a 55-year-old resident of Dillon, Montana, was a Montana State University student in 1996, studying fisheries and wildlife biology. He later worked for the Bureau of Land Management for 22 years, was married, and had two adult children. He had no criminal history, making him an unlikely suspect. Investigators believed Hutchinson and Danni had no prior connection, describing the crime as one of opportunity. They theorized that Hutchinson encountered Danni at the river, raped her, and suffocated her in shallow water.

In July 2024, investigators, led by Elfmont, interviewed Hutchinson. He displayed extreme nervousness, sweating profusely, scratching his face, and chewing his hand. When shown a photo of Danni, he slumped in his chair, visibly uncomfortable. After the nearly two-hour interview, Hutchinson’s behavior became erratic. At 4:17 a.m. on July 24, he called the Beaverhead County Sheriff’s Office, requesting assistance before hanging up. Deputies found him dead shortly after, having taken his own life with a gunshot wound. Subsequent DNA testing confirmed a complete match between Hutchinson’s DNA and the evidence from Danni’s body.

Closure Without a Trial

The confirmation of Hutchinson as Danni’s killer brought bittersweet closure to her family. “After nearly 28 years without answers, without justice, we celebrate today,” Stephanie Mollet said at a press conference on August 8, 2024. She expressed certainty that Hutchinson was the one who assaulted and murdered her sister, holding her head down in the marsh until she choked on mud. While Hutchinson’s death meant there would be no trial, the truth had finally emerged.

Gallatin County Sheriff Dan Springer praised the team’s persistence, stating, “This case exemplifies our relentless pursuit of justice. We never gave up on finding the truth for Danni and her family.” The “48 Hours” episode highlights this dedication, showcasing how advancements in forensic science and the family’s unwavering resolve brought answers after decades of uncertainty.

A Community’s Reflection

The “It’s About Danni” episode also captures the emotional toll on Belgrade, a small town unaccustomed to such violence. Rachelle Schrute, a friend of the Houchins family and now an editor at GearJunkie, recalled the fear that gripped the community in 1996. “The rumors started flying of maybe it was a murder,” she told “48 Hours.” The resolution of the case, nearly three decades later, brought relief but also reopened old wounds for those who knew Danni.

For viewers, the episode is a powerful reminder of the impact of cold cases on families and communities. It underscores the importance of perseverance and the role of modern technology in solving crimes once thought unsolvable. Peter Van Sant’s reporting, combined with personal accounts from Stephanie Mollet and others, paints a vivid picture of a family’s fight for truth and a town forever changed by loss.

How to Watch

The “48 Hours” episode “It’s About Danni” aired on February 8, 2025, at 10 p.m. ET/9 p.m. MT on CBS and is available for streaming on Paramount+. For those interested in learning more about this gripping case, the episode offers an in-depth look at the investigation, the family’s journey, and the scientific breakthroughs that finally revealed the truth behind Danni Houchins’ death.

This story is a testament to the power of hope, the strength of family, and the relentless pursuit of justice, no matter how much time has passed.

Also know :- Netskope Taps Morgan Stanley for U.S. IPO, Aiming for $5 Billion Valuation