Black voter support for Trump is falling, according to multiple polls leading up to the 2024 U.S. presidential election. While the former president once showed surprising signs of growth among Black voters in 2020, recent data suggests that this momentum is fading.
This article explores why Black voter support for Trump is sinking, what’s driving the shift, how Democrats are responding, and what it all could mean for November 2024.
What the Polls Are Showing
Several recent polls highlight a significant drop in Black voter enthusiasm for Donald Trump. A late June poll by The New York Times and Siena College showed Trump trailing President Joe Biden among Black voters by over 60 percentage points—a much wider gap than his campaign had hoped for.
While Trump received around 12 percent of the Black vote in 2020, new polling data shows that number dipping to single digits again. Other surveys, including those from Pew Research and Gallup, also reflect this downward trend in support.
Key Numbers at a Glance:
- NYT/Siena June 2024: 6% Black voter support for Trump
- Pew Research March 2024: 8% Black voter support for Trump
- Gallup April 2024: 7% of Black Americans approve of Trump’s leadership
These numbers paint a clear picture: Black voter support for Trump is on the decline as the election nears.
What’s Behind the Drop?
1. Criminal Convictions and Legal Troubles
Trump’s multiple indictments, ongoing court cases, and criminal convictions have significantly damaged his public image—especially among Black voters who are generally more skeptical of political corruption.
For many, seeing a presidential candidate with felony convictions is a major red flag. Although Trump claims the justice system is being weaponized against him, that message is not resonating well in Black communities that have historically experienced over-policing and systemic injustice.
2. Disconnection From Black Communities
During his presidency, Trump often claimed he had done more for Black Americans than any other president since Abraham Lincoln. But many Black voters don’t agree.
Initiatives like criminal justice reform and Opportunity Zones had limited visibility in the everyday lives of many Black families. Critics argue that Trump’s administration often failed to understand the deep-rooted issues affecting these communities, such as education, housing inequality, and police reform.
His messaging, often perceived as combative and racially insensitive—especially after the George Floyd protests—also alienated many Black voters.
3. The Rise of New Democratic Outreach
The Democratic Party, despite its challenges, has been actively investing in community engagement in key swing states. In states like Georgia, Pennsylvania, and Michigan, local Black leaders and organizers have been mobilizing efforts to ensure high voter turnout.
Groups like Black Voters Matter and the NAACP have stepped up efforts to educate voters, fight voter suppression, and counter right-wing narratives.
These grassroots movements have played a crucial role in reshaping how many Black voters perceive the 2024 election—not just as a choice between two candidates, but as a broader fight for democracy and civil rights.
The Role of Messaging and Social Media
Trump’s communication style—marked by aggressive rhetoric and inflammatory posts—has long been polarizing. His efforts to attract Black voters in 2020 included photo-ops with celebrities, catchy slogans like “What have you got to lose?” and highlighting prison reform.
However, those strategies now appear outdated or hollow to many Black voters, especially younger ones who are highly active on social media and quick to fact-check political claims.
A rising number of Black content creators and influencers have also taken to platforms like TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram to call out misinformation and challenge Trump’s record.
How This Shift Could Impact the 2024 Election
Black voters are a key demographic for Democrats, especially in battleground states. But even a small swing toward or away from a candidate can change the outcome in tight races.
While Biden is still heavily favored among Black voters, Democratic strategists know they can’t take that support for granted. At the same time, the loss of even a few percentage points from Trump’s side makes his path to victory more difficult.
For example:
- In Georgia, where Biden won by just 11,779 votes in 2020, Black voter turnout played a major role.
- In Wisconsin, Trump lost by about 20,000 votes—a margin where Black support or lack of it could swing the state.
The fact that Black voter support for Trump is shrinking suggests Biden might once again be able to count on this crucial demographic to hold back Republican gains.
Could the GOP Still Recover?
Trump’s campaign has launched efforts like “Black Voices for Trump,” but many analysts say the initiative lacks authenticity and depth. The focus has largely been on high-profile endorsements rather than genuine grassroots outreach.
In contrast, Democrats have invested more in local Black communities, faith leaders, and historically Black colleges and universities.
If Trump hopes to regain support, he’ll need to do more than talk about the past—he’ll need to offer real solutions to today’s issues: police reform, economic inequality, voting rights, and more.
Disapproval Beyond the Polls
Aside from the numbers, there are visible signs of discontent. At rallies and events, the presence of Black supporters is minimal. Online communities that once praised Trump’s outsider status have grown quieter or shifted focus.
Even Black Republicans like Tim Scott, while supporting the GOP overall, have taken a more neutral tone regarding Trump’s future. The enthusiasm that once came from certain sectors of the Black community appears to be fading.
Generational Divide in Black Voters
It’s important to note that not all Black voters think alike. In fact, a growing generational divide is emerging:
- Older Black voters (55+) tend to remain loyal to the Democratic Party and are strongly anti-Trump
- Younger Black voters (18–35), while still leaning Democratic, are more critical of both parties and more likely to consider third-party or independent candidates
But even among younger voters, Trump is not gaining ground. Many are turning away from politics altogether or favoring more progressive voices, like those advocating for climate justice, student loan forgiveness, and universal healthcare—issues Trump rarely addresses.
What Needs to Happen Next
For Democrats:
- Maintain strong community engagement
- Address economic concerns, especially inflation and job growth
- Show real progress on civil rights, police accountability, and education
For Republicans:
- Move beyond surface-level messaging
- Build trust through long-term engagement, not just election-year promises
- Offer serious policies that address systemic issues facing Black communities
Final Thoughts
Black voter support for Trump is sinking, and the numbers show it. His legal troubles, lack of effective messaging, and failure to connect with Black communities are key reasons behind this trend.
While the race for the White House remains competitive, Trump faces an uphill battle when it comes to winning back the trust of Black voters. And without that support, the road to 270 electoral votes becomes even steeper.
As the 2024 election draws near, one thing is clear: Black voters will once again play a decisive role in shaping America’s future.
Read Next – Churches Can Endorse Political Candidates, Says IRS
