In 2018, the small town of Frederick, Colorado, became the epicenter of one of the most disturbing murder cases in recent history. Chris Watts brutally killed his pregnant wife, Shanann, and their two young daughters, Bella and Celeste. As investigators unraveled the crime, one name repeatedly surfaced—Nichol Kessinger, Watts’ mistress. Her involvement in the case, albeit indirect, played a crucial role in bringing the truth to light. Years later, the world still wonders: Where is Nichol Kessinger now?
Born in 1988 in Colorado, Nichol Kessinger pursued a career in geology. She attended Colorado State University, where she earned a Bachelor of Science degree in 2013, focusing on geology. Additionally, she obtained an Associate of Science degree from the Community College of Aurora. By 2018, she was employed at Anadarko Petroleum Corporation, where she met Chris Watts.
According to reports, Kessinger was described as a bright and hardworking professional. She had no prior criminal history and lived a relatively quiet life before crossing paths with Watts.
Kessinger and Watts began their relationship in the summer of 2018. Watts, however, deceived Kessinger from the start. He told her he was separated from his wife and finalizing a divorce. Unbeknownst to Kessinger, Shanann was not only very much in the picture but also pregnant with their third child.
Their relationship progressed quickly, with Watts telling Kessinger that they had a future together. She later stated that she believed he was a single father trying to move on from a failed marriage. However, this illusion shattered when Shanann and her daughters went missing on August 13, 2018.
As media coverage of the missing Watts family intensified, Kessinger began to notice inconsistencies in Watts’ behavior. He seemed unusually calm despite his family’s disappearance. When she searched for his wife’s name online, she discovered that Shanann was pregnant, something Watts had never disclosed.
Realizing she had been deceived, Kessinger decided to cooperate with law enforcement. On August 15, 2018, she contacted the Weld County Sheriff’s Office to disclose her relationship with Watts and share any relevant information. Investigators considered her a key witness, as her testimony and phone records helped build the case against Watts.
Initially, Watts claimed he had no idea where his family was. However, after failing a polygraph test and facing mounting evidence, he confessed. He admitted to strangling Shanann after an argument and later smothering his daughters before disposing of their bodies in oil tanks at his workplace.
Watts pleaded guilty to multiple counts of first-degree murder and was sentenced to life in prison without parole. Kessinger’s cooperation had played a significant role in closing the case, but it also changed her life forever.
In the wake of the murders, Kessinger became a subject of intense scrutiny. Despite her willingness to assist investigators, many people blamed her for the tragic outcome, arguing that her affair with Watts fueled his actions.
She faced relentless online harassment, death threats, and public outrage. Some conspiracy theorists even speculated that she had been more involved in the crime than she admitted, though authorities never found any evidence to support such claims.
Due to the overwhelming backlash, Kessinger reportedly changed her identity and relocated. Some sources suggest she entered a witness protection-type program to shield herself from the relentless media and public attention. However, official details about her whereabouts remain undisclosed.
In 2021, reports surfaced that Kessinger might have attempted to reach out to Watts while he was incarcerated. An inmate named David Carter, who claimed to have befriended Watts in prison, alleged that Watts received letters from Kessinger under a new identity. According to Carter, Watts mentioned that Kessinger wanted to “clear things up.”
These claims, however, remain unverified. Kessinger has not made any public statements since her initial interviews with law enforcement in 2018.
The case regained widespread attention in 2020 with the release of Netflix’s documentary “American Murder: The Family Next Door.” The film provided an in-depth look at the events leading up to the murders, featuring archival footage, text messages, and police interviews. Although Kessinger did not participate in the documentary, her role in the case was scrutinized again, sparking renewed public discussions.
True crime enthusiasts, podcasters, and YouTubers continue to analyze every aspect of the case, keeping Kessinger’s name relevant in discussions. While some sympathize with her as an unknowing participant in Watts’ web of lies, others still question her involvement.
Maintaining anonymity in the digital age is nearly impossible, especially for individuals linked to high-profile cases. Reports indicate that Kessinger took extensive measures to disappear from public life. It is believed she changed her name, moved to a new location, and cut ties with former acquaintances.
Despite the drastic steps she has taken, public curiosity remains high. Online forums and social media users continue to speculate about her current status, though there has been no confirmed sighting or reliable update in years.
Nichol Kessinger’s involvement in the Chris Watts case serves as a cautionary tale about the unforeseen consequences of deception and betrayal. While Watts serves multiple life sentences for his heinous crimes, Kessinger has been left to rebuild her life under a cloud of suspicion and relentless public scrutiny.
Whether she was a victim of Watts’ lies or an enabler of his actions remains a point of contention. However, one thing is clear: the tragic events of 2018 changed her life forever. As time passes, the question remains—will she ever truly escape the shadow of one of America’s most infamous family murders?
Standing tall against the shimmering waters of Lake Michigan, Chicago’s skyline is more than a…
Chicago’s Riverwalk is more than just a scenic stretch of waterfront—it’s a celebration of the…
New York City is vast and ever-changing, but no borough captures its creative pulse quite…
When Resorts World Las Vegas opened its doors in 2021, it was billed as a…
Las Vegas may be known for over-the-top luxury, but it also offers something wonderfully unexpected—world-famous…
Las Vegas has always been synonymous with extravagance, but in 2025, the city’s most elite…