Sports

Cincinnati Reds Trade Former All-Star Alexis Diaz to Los Angeles Dodgers in Bold Move

Chicago, May 30, 2025 – In a surprising turn of events, the Cincinnati Reds have traded their former All-Star closer Alexis Diaz to the Los Angeles Dodgers, marking the end of a significant chapter for the Reds and a new opportunity for Diaz in Los Angeles. The trade, announced on Thursday, sees the Reds sending the right-handed relief pitcher to the Dodgers in exchange for minor league pitcher Mike Villani. This move comes after a challenging 2025 season for Diaz, who struggled to regain his 2023 All-Star form, prompting the Reds to make a tough but strategic decision.

A Promising Start Fades

Alexis Diaz burst onto the Major League Baseball scene in 2022, quickly establishing himself as a reliable closer for the Cincinnati Reds. Over his first three seasons, he amassed an impressive 75 saves and an 18-14 record, with his standout performance coming in 2023 when he earned 37 saves and a National League All-Star nod. His ability to generate strikeouts with a sharp slider and command the mound made him a fan favorite and a cornerstone of the Reds’ bullpen.

However, the 2025 season told a different story. Diaz began the year on the 15-day injured list with a left hamstring strain, which sidelined him through spring training. After returning on April 15, his performance was inconsistent. In six innings pitched, he posted a staggering 12.00 ERA and a 2.167 WHIP, allowing eight runs and striking out only three batters. A particularly rough outing against the St. Louis Cardinals on April 30, where he gave up five earned runs and three home runs in just one inning, led to his demotion to Triple-A Louisville on May 1.

In Triple-A, Diaz continued to struggle, recording a 4.63 ERA with a 1-2 record and two saves in 14 appearances. Despite efforts to refine his mechanics, the Reds and Diaz could not recapture the magic of his earlier seasons. “Diaz is 22½ months from an All-Star appearance and hasn’t done what they’ve asked to fix his issues,” one X post noted, reflecting the sentiment among some Reds fans that the team had exhausted its options with the pitcher.

Reds’ Decision to Move On

The Reds’ decision to trade Diaz signals a shift in strategy as they look to rebuild and focus on long-term goals. Cincinnati has yet to advance in the postseason in recent years, and the organization appears ready to explore new talent to bolster their roster. General Manager Nick Krall described the trade as a necessary step, noting the potential of Mike Villani, the minor league pitcher acquired from the Dodgers. “Good arm strength, he can spin a breaking ball,” Krall said of Villani, highlighting his upside despite being a recently drafted prospect.

The trade also reflects a missed opportunity for the Reds, who reportedly received multiple serious offers for Diaz during his peak in 2023. According to Sports Illustrated, the Reds’ decision to hold onto Diaz at the time may have cost them a more substantial return compared to the single minor leaguer they received in this deal. “Diaz was once in demand, but the Reds passed on that and ultimately guessed wrong,” the outlet reported, underscoring the risks of holding onto players past their prime trade value.

A New Chapter for Diaz in Los Angeles

For the Los Angeles Dodgers, acquiring Alexis Diaz is a calculated gamble to strengthen their injury-riddled bullpen. The Dodgers have faced significant challenges this season, with high-leverage relievers like Brusdar Graterol, Michael Kopech, Blake Treinen, Kirby Yates, and Evan Phillips on the injured list. To accommodate Diaz on the 40-man roster, the Dodgers transferred Phillips to the 60-day injured list, signaling their urgency to bolster their relief pitching.

Diaz’s role with the Dodgers remains uncertain, but the team hopes he can rediscover the form that made him a dominant closer. “His slider has been a weapon for him to generate whiffs and strikeouts,” one X user commented, expressing optimism that the Dodgers’ pitching coaches, led by Mark Prior, could help Diaz turn things around. Los Angeles has a strong track record of rehabilitating pitchers, and Diaz’s relatively low salary of approximately $4.5 million for the 2025 season, combined with two more years of arbitration eligibility, makes him an attractive long-term investment.

The Dodgers’ bullpen needs are pressing, especially as they aim to maintain their competitive edge in the National League. While Diaz is unlikely to immediately assume the closer role, his experience and potential could provide much-needed depth. “The Dodgers need fresh arms,” one fan posted on X, echoing the sentiment that Diaz’s arrival comes at a critical time for the team.

Fan Reactions and Broader Implications

The trade has sparked a range of reactions from fans and analysts. Reds supporters expressed mixed feelings, with some lamenting the end of the “Alexis Diaz era.” One X post described his journey poignantly: “He rose out of nowhere (12th round draft pick) to become an All-Star closer, then faded back into obscurity.” Others criticized the Reds’ management for not capitalizing on Diaz’s value sooner, while Dodgers fans remain cautiously optimistic about his potential to rebound.

This trade also highlights broader trends in Major League Baseball, where teams must balance short-term needs with long-term planning. The Reds’ decision to part ways with Diaz underscores the challenges of managing player development and trade value in a competitive league. Meanwhile, the Dodgers’ willingness to take a chance on a struggling but talented pitcher reflects their aggressive approach to roster building.

Looking Ahead

For Alexis Diaz, the move to Los Angeles offers a fresh start. At 28 years old, he has time to refine his mechanics and regain his confidence under the guidance of a new coaching staff. His ability to generate strikeouts with his slider and his experience as a closer could make him a valuable asset if he can overcome his recent struggles.

For the Reds, the trade marks a step toward reshaping their roster for future contention. While Mike Villani may not immediately impact the major league team, his potential as a developing pitcher offers hope for the Reds’ farm system. As Cincinnati continues to build, fans will be watching closely to see how this trade shapes the team’s trajectory.

The baseball world will keep an eye on Diaz as he joins a Dodgers team hungry for success. Whether he can reclaim his All-Star form remains to be seen, but this trade represents a pivotal moment for both the pitcher and the teams involved. For now, Reds fans bid farewell to a once-dominant closer, while Dodgers fans welcome a player with the potential to make a difference.

Sources: