Former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo has been quietly laying the groundwork for a return to politics. But a rising star in New York’s progressive wing, Zohran Mamdani, may be the unexpected force standing in his way. As Cuomo tests the waters for a political comeback, Mamdani’s growing popularity and influence among young, left-leaning voters could present a serious challenge to the former governor’s redemption plan.
In this article, we’ll explore why Cuomo’s political comeback may not go as smoothly as he hopes, and how Zohran Mamdani is playing a key role in shaping a new political landscape in New York.
Who Is Andrew Cuomo?
Andrew Cuomo is a well-known figure in American politics. He served as the Governor of New York from 2011 to 2021, gaining national attention for his handling of the COVID-19 pandemic—until his career took a sharp turn. Accused of multiple sexual harassment allegations and criticized for underreporting COVID deaths in nursing homes, Cuomo resigned under pressure in August 2021.
Since then, he has kept a relatively low profile, but insiders say he’s considering a return to public office. Cuomo has hinted at his frustration over what he calls “cancel culture” and “political attacks,” and has reportedly been meeting with political allies and donors behind the scenes.
But times have changed. The political environment in New York is no longer what it was during Cuomo’s prime. And that’s where Zohran Mamdani enters the picture.
Meet Zohran Mamdani: The Progressive Challenger
Zohran Mamdani is a 32-year-old state assembly member representing New York’s 36th district in Queens. Born in Uganda and raised in New York City, Mamdani is the son of Indian filmmaker Mira Nair and Columbia professor Mahmood Mamdani. He’s a member of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) and is known for his strong progressive stance on housing, healthcare, and workers’ rights.
Since being elected in 2020, Mamdani has been at the forefront of several high-profile campaigns, including:
- Fighting to cancel rent during the pandemic.
- Advocating for universal healthcare in New York.
- Supporting a Green New Deal for the state.
- Taking on powerful real estate developers.
What makes Mamdani stand out is not just his policies, but his ability to mobilize young voters. He has built a solid grassroots base and uses platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and community events to reach his audience. For many, he represents a fresh, bold alternative to the older generation of Democrats like Cuomo.
Why Cuomo’s Political Comeback Is Complicated
1. Reputation Still Tarnished
Despite Cuomo’s efforts to paint himself as a victim of political sabotage, public opinion hasn’t fully recovered. Polls suggest that while he retains some support among older voters and moderate Democrats, younger progressives see him as part of the problem—not the solution.
2. New Political Landscape
The Democratic Party in New York has shifted. The progressive wing, led by figures like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Jabari Brisport, and Zohran Mamdani, has grown in power. They’re pushing policies that go far beyond Cuomo’s centrist legacy, and they’re resonating with voters under 40.
3. Grassroots Momentum
Mamdani’s influence goes beyond his district. As a rising figure in state politics, he’s been helping progressive candidates across the state, including challenging establishment Democrats in primaries. If Cuomo attempts to return, he may find himself targeted by a well-organized grassroots campaign determined to keep the old guard out.
Cuomo vs. Mamdani: Not a Direct Battle, but a Symbolic One
At the moment, Cuomo and Mamdani aren’t running against each other for the same seat. However, the clash between them is more ideological than electoral. Cuomo represents the old-school, establishment wing of the Democratic Party—experienced, pragmatic, and deeply connected to party machinery. Mamdani represents a new wave—youthful, idealistic, and powered by activism.
This contrast makes Mamdani a natural foil to Cuomo. If Cuomo runs for office again, Mamdani could become a key voice opposing him, rallying younger voters and the left-wing base against any attempt to bring Cuomo back into power.
The Power of the Progressive Base
In recent years, the progressive movement in New York has had significant wins:
- AOC’s victory in 2018 over longtime incumbent Joe Crowley.
- State-level wins by candidates like Julia Salazar, Jabari Brisport, and Zohran Mamdani.
- DSA-backed legislation on housing, climate, and healthcare gaining traction.
These victories show that progressives aren’t just a fringe group—they’re reshaping the political core of New York. This is bad news for Cuomo’s political comeback, which relies on a political environment more friendly to moderates and centrists.
Key Issues That Could Define the Battle
Housing
Mamdani has been a strong advocate for rent stabilization and tenant rights, while Cuomo’s past ties to real estate developers have raised questions. In a state where affordable housing is a crisis, this contrast could hurt Cuomo’s appeal.
Criminal Justice
Mamdani supports significant reforms to policing and incarceration. Cuomo’s record on criminal justice is mixed, which may turn off the younger base demanding deeper reforms.
Climate Policy
Mamdani backs aggressive climate legislation, including a state-level Green New Deal. Cuomo made some progress in this area but was often seen as compromising too much with corporate interests.
Media & Messaging Wars
Cuomo is a media veteran with strong connections and name recognition. He can easily command attention and dominate traditional media cycles. Mamdani, however, excels in digital spaces, particularly among Gen Z and Millennials. His videos, tweets, and grassroots videos often go viral, helping him reach thousands at a time without relying on traditional news outlets.
The fight for public perception may not play out on TV—it’ll likely unfold on social media platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube, where Mamdani’s voice is far louder than Cuomo’s.
What Do the Voters Think?
While Cuomo still has pockets of support, particularly in suburban and older urban areas, the political winds have shifted. A recent poll conducted by Siena College showed that:
- Only 31% of New Yorkers believe Cuomo should run for office again.
- 58% of Democratic voters under 40 say they prefer “new progressive voices.”
- 44% of voters said they are more likely to support a candidate endorsed by DSA or progressive leaders.
These numbers suggest that Cuomo may face a steep uphill climb—not just from political opponents, but from the mood of the electorate itself.
What’s Next for Cuomo and Mamdani?
Cuomo has not officially announced a campaign but is reportedly eyeing several possibilities, including a run for Attorney General or even a U.S. Senate seat. However, any move he makes will be watched closely by the progressive left—and Mamdani may become one of the loudest voices pushing back.
Mamdani, on the other hand, is continuing to expand his influence. Whether or not he runs for higher office himself, his role in shaping the state’s political narrative is only growing.
Final Thoughts: A Generational Tug of War
The tension between Cuomo and Mamdani isn’t just about two politicians—it’s about what direction New York’s Democratic Party should go. Will voters choose a return to familiar leadership and experience? Or will they embrace a bold, progressive future led by voices like Zohran Mamdani?
In the end, Cuomo’s political comeback may depend less on his own actions and more on the mood of the electorate—and right now, that mood seems to favor change.
Read Next – Who is Zohran Mamdani? Challenger Neck and Neck with Former Gov. Cuomo in NYC Mayor Race
