Frozen Pizza Brands Ranked: The Best, Worst, and Surprising Picks!

Frozen pizza is one of the most convenient and beloved comfort foods worldwide. Whether you’re craving a quick meal or stocking up for a lazy night, the freezer aisle is packed with options. But not all frozen pizzas are created equal. Some brands offer restaurant-quality flavors, while others fall flat with bland toppings and soggy crusts. So, which ones are worth your money? We tasted and ranked some of the most popular frozen pizza brands to help you make the best choice.

The Criteria

To ensure a fair ranking, we evaluated each frozen pizza based on the following factors:

• Crust: Is it crispy, chewy, or disappointingly soggy?
• Sauce: Does it have a bold and tangy flavor or is it too sweet and artificial?
• Cheese: Is it gooey, flavorful, and generous?
• Toppings: Are they fresh, high-quality, and well-balanced?
• Overall Taste & Value: Considering price, portion, and quality, is it worth buying?

The Best Frozen Pizza Brands

1. DiGiorno – The Premium Pick

DiGiorno is a household name in the frozen pizza world, and for a good reason. Their signature rising crust makes it feel like a fresh-baked pizzeria experience. The crust is thick, airy, and crispy on the outside, while the sauce is well-seasoned and slightly tangy. The cheese and toppings are generous, making it one of the best choices if you’re looking for a high-quality frozen pizza.

• Pros: Excellent crust, good cheese coverage, flavorful sauce
• Cons: More expensive than other brands

2. Tombstone – A Classic Favorite

Tombstone has been around for decades, delivering a satisfying frozen pizza experience at an affordable price. The thin, crispy crust, balanced sauce, and ample cheese make it a great option for those who love a traditional frozen pizza taste.

• Pros: Budget-friendly, crispy crust, decent toppings
• Cons: Not as filling as thicker crust options

3. Newman’s Own – Best for Quality Ingredients

If you prefer an all-natural option, Newman’s Own is a great choice. The brand prides itself on using high-quality ingredients with no artificial preservatives. The crust is thin and slightly crunchy, while the sauce has a fresh tomato taste. Plus, profits go to charity, making it a win-win for your taste buds and a good cause.

• Pros: Healthier option, great flavor, supports charity
• Cons: More expensive, limited variety

The Worst Frozen Pizza Brands

1. Totino’s – Better as a Snack, Not a Meal

Totino’s Party Pizzas are a nostalgic favorite, but they don’t compare to other frozen pizzas. The crust is very thin and almost cracker-like, while the toppings can be sparse. It’s more of a snack than a full meal, but for its low price, it has its place.

• Pros: Cheap, crispy crust, good for snacking
• Cons: Minimal toppings, not filling, low-quality cheese

2. Red Baron – Mediocre at Best

While Red Baron has a dedicated fanbase, it falls short compared to other brands. The crust is often too dry, and the sauce lacks depth. While it’s not the worst frozen pizza, there are better options at a similar price point.

• Pros: Decent price, good cheese melt
• Cons: Dry crust, bland sauce

Surprise Hits: Hidden Gems in the Frozen Aisle

1. California Pizza Kitchen – Gourmet Flavors in Frozen Form

CPK brings restaurant-style flavors to your home with unique toppings like BBQ Chicken and White Pizza. The crust is thin and crispy, and the flavors are more sophisticated than your average frozen pizza.

• Pros: High-end taste, unique flavor combinations
• Cons: Higher price, not as traditional

2. Screamin’ Sicilian – Loaded with Toppings

This brand has been gaining popularity for its generous toppings and hearty crust. If you love a pizza loaded with cheese and meats, Screamin’ Sicilian is a great option. The crust is thick and satisfying, and the sauce is bold and flavorful.

• Pros: Lots of toppings, thick and crispy crust
• Cons: More expensive than average frozen pizzas

Final Verdict

When it comes to frozen pizza, your choice depends on what you’re looking for. If you want a top-tier, restaurant-quality experience, DiGiorno or California Pizza Kitchen are excellent picks. For those on a budget, Tombstone or Totino’s can satisfy a quick craving. If quality ingredients matter most, Newman’s Own is the way to go. And if you’re looking for something heavy on toppings, Screamin’ Sicilian won’t disappoint.

No matter your choice, one thing is certain—there’s a frozen pizza for everyone. So next time you’re in the frozen aisle, use this guide to pick the best one for your next pizza night!

The Secret to NYT’s Buttermilk Pancakes: Why Everyone’s Obsessed!