Car theft continues to be a major concern for vehicle owners across the United States. Each year, thousands of cars are reported stolen, with some models being prime targets for criminals. But what makes a car more likely to be stolen? Factors like high resale value, demand for spare parts, and outdated security features all play a role.

The National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) has recently released updated data highlighting the most and least stolen vehicles in the U.S. for the past year. This report breaks down that information and helps you understand what’s driving car theft—and how to stay safe.
Top 5 Most Stolen Cars in the U.S. (Based on NICB Data)
1. Hyundai Elantra (Year: 2017 model most targeted)
This compact sedan has soared to the top of the stolen vehicle list. In 2023 alone, over 43,000 Hyundai Elantras were reported stolen. Why? Older models lack engine immobilizers, making them vulnerable to easy theft, particularly through viral social media hacks.
2. Kia Optima (Year: 2015 model most targeted)
Just like Hyundai, certain Kia models were targeted heavily due to similar missing security features. The Kia Optima, a mid-sized sedan, saw nearly 38,000 thefts, primarily in urban areas. The company has responded by rolling out software updates and anti-theft kits.
3. Chevrolet Silverado (Year: 2004 model most targeted)
The Silverado, a full-size pickup truck, continues to be a favorite among thieves, with over 35,000 reported thefts. Its popularity and high resale value on the black market for parts make it a frequent target.
4. Honda Accord (Year: 1997 model most targeted)
Despite being an older model, the Honda Accord remains one of the most stolen cars in America. More than 32,000 Accords were stolen last year, with older versions being particularly vulnerable due to outdated security systems and high demand for parts.
5. Honda Civic (Year: 2000 model most targeted)
Rounding out the top five is the Honda Civic, another long-time target for thieves. Its consistent popularity, ease of breaking into, and resale value make it a continuing threat to owners. Over 30,000 Civics were stolen in 2023.
5 Least Stolen Cars in the U.S. (Safest Bets for Car Buyers)
1. Tesla Model Y
The Tesla Model Y tops the list of least stolen cars. With its advanced GPS tracking, over-the-air updates, and constant connectivity to owner smartphones, Tesla vehicles are difficult to steal and even harder to get away with.
2. Volvo XC90
Known for its top-tier safety features and advanced anti-theft systems, the Volvo XC90 had among the fewest reported thefts nationwide. The SUV is built with complex electronic locking systems and encrypted key fobs.
3. Subaru Forester
This practical crossover SUV is not only great for outdoor lovers but also a rare target for thieves. The Subaru Forester’s low theft rate is attributed to its strong safety scores, moderate resale value, and reliable security measures.
4. BMW X5
While high-end cars are often seen as theft magnets, the BMW X5 proves otherwise. With high-tech anti-theft tools like motion sensors, remote shutdown, and integrated alarms, it remains one of the safest luxury vehicles in terms of theft.
5. Lexus RX 350
The Lexus RX 350 rounds out the list. This midsize luxury SUV has a reputation for safety and durability. Enhanced security systems, including immobilizers and real-time GPS tracking, keep it safe from theft attempts.
Why Are Some Cars Stolen More Than Others?
Several reasons contribute to why certain vehicles are more likely to be stolen:
- Lack of anti-theft technology: Older vehicles without immobilizers are easier to hotwire or start without a key.
- High demand for parts: Popular cars like the Honda Civic or Accord are in high demand for used parts, making them attractive to thieves.
- Social media trends: Recently, TikTok and YouTube videos have demonstrated how to steal cars with poor ignition security, particularly affecting Hyundai and Kia models.
- Owner negligence: Leaving keys in the car, windows open, or parking in unsafe areas increases theft risk.
How to Protect Your Car from Theft
If you own one of the top stolen models, don’t panic—there are steps you can take:
- Install a steering wheel lock or kill switch
- Use a GPS tracker or security system
- Park in well-lit, secure areas
- Keep your keys safe and never leave your car running unattended
- Upgrade to newer security software if available (Hyundai and Kia owners can request updates)
Insurance Implications
Cars that are stolen more frequently usually carry higher insurance premiums. If you’re purchasing a used vehicle, consider checking its theft rate before making a decision. Some insurance companies offer discounts for anti-theft devices, so investing in added protection could save you money in the long run.
Conclusion
Knowing which cars are most and least targeted by thieves can help you make smarter choices as a vehicle owner. While some cars naturally attract more attention from criminals, preventive action and proper technology can drastically reduce your risk. If you’re considering a new or used car, pay attention to its theft history—because owning the “wrong” car could cost you more than just the sticker price.
Useful Resources for Further Reading:
- NICB Official Vehicle Theft Report
- Consumer Reports on Anti-Theft Systems
- Insurance Tips for High-Theft Vehicles
Also Read – Maserati Grecale vs AMG GLC 63: SUV Drag Race Shock!