5 Big Takeaways from Don Garber on Messi’s MLS All-Star Absence

The 2025 MLS All-Star Game came and went, but one name was painfully missing from the star-studded lineup Lionel Messi. As the biggest name in Major League Soccer today, Messi’s absence from the marquee match created frustration among fans and triggered public backlash.

Now, MLS Commissioner Don Garber has spoken publicly about the situation, admitting that the league should have handled it better. His comments shed light on internal miscommunication, expectations, and the challenges of managing global superstars in American soccer.

Here are five major takeaways from Garber’s remarks and what they mean for the league, the fans, and Messi’s future MLS involvement.

1.Don Garber Says Messi’s Absence Was Known Too Late

One of the main points Garber addressed was the lack of clear and timely communication. According to him, Messi’s non-participation in the All-Star Game was not confirmed early enough for the league to respond appropriately.

Many fans traveled and bought tickets specifically hoping to watch play. The expectation was that the league’s biggest attraction would take the field in Columbus, Ohio, where the 2025 All-Star event was held.

Garber admitted that had MLS known about his decision or his unavailability earlier, they could have communicated it better, possibly avoiding fan disappointment and media criticism.

2. Messi’s Focus Remained on Club Play and Health

While Messi has remained a strong supporter of growing soccer in the U.S., sources close to Inter Miami suggested the Argentine star wanted to focus on club matches and manage his physical load.

Inter Miami is currently in a competitive push for the playoffs, and Messi’s limited appearances this summer have been closely managed due to lingering muscle concerns and the busy travel schedule.

Garber acknowledged that player health must be a top priority. However, he also stressed that when a player like joins MLS, there’s a level of commitment expected toward league events especially one as high-profile as the All-Star Game.

3. Fans Deserved Better Communication from MLS

The backlash from Messi’s absence was not just about his no-show. Fans were mostly upset with the lack of early notice. Many were led to believe that Messi would play and felt blindsided when he didn’t appear on the team sheet.

Garber admitted this was a major oversight. He emphasized that the league must do a better job of managing expectations and ensuring that fans have the information they need to make informed decisions.

This incident could lead to future policy changes around how All-Star rosters are announced and how injuries or absences are communicated in real time.

4. Messi Still Committed to MLS Growth

Despite missing the All-Star Game, Garber reiterated that Messi’s presence in MLS has already transformed the league. From increased ticket sales and global media attention to packed stadiums and improved TV ratings, Messi’s impact is undeniable.

According to league data, Inter Miami’s matches have become the most-watched games in MLS history. Merchandise sales for Messi jerseys have broken all records.

Garber believes that while the All-Star absence was a disappointment, it does not take away from his larger contribution to American soccer. He expects Messi to remain actively involved in future league events, including the playoffs and community appearances.

5. The All-Star Format Could Change in the Future

In the wake of this controversy, Garber hinted that the All-Star Game format itself may be due for a revamp. Over the years, the MLS All-Star Game has evolved from East vs. West to MLS vs. international clubs, and more recently, MLS vs. Liga MX All-Stars.

This year’s event saw a mixed reaction even before Messi’s absence. Some critics argue the All-Star format lacks meaning and places unnecessary pressure on players during a busy season.

Garber stated the league is open to new ideas possibly even scrapping the game altogether or replacing it with a fan festival, skills competition, or exhibition involving legends and young rising stars.

While no changes have been confirmed, the episode has sparked internal debate on how the All-Star experience can be made more relevant and enjoyable for fans and players alike.

Reactions from Fans and Players

Fan reaction on social media was swift and sharp. Many expressed frustration after attending the event only to realize Messi was not playing.

One fan comment summarized the mood: “This felt like false advertising. We came for Messi, not just the MLS brand.”

Some MLS players, while not directly blaming him, suggested that transparency should have been prioritized. Others pointed out that no single player should define the success or failure of an entire event.

Despite the controversy, the game itself a showdown between MLS All-Stars and the best of Liga MX still drew over 20,000 fans in attendance and thousands more watching across the globe.

Messi’s Next Steps with Inter Miami

As Inter Miami heads into the second half of the MLS season, Messi’s availability remains a hot topic. His workload is being managed carefully by head coach Tata Martino, with a focus on keeping him fresh for the playoffs.

Expected to feature in key league fixtures, Leagues Cup matches, and potentially the U.S. Open Cup.

Garber confirmed there are no disciplinary measures for missing the All-Star Game. However, future participation in league-wide events may come with clearer guidelines and expectations especially for international stars like him.

Final Thoughts

The fallout from Lionel Messi missing the 2025 MLS All-Star Game has raised important questions about communication, player priorities, and league planning.

Don Garber’s response was honest and reflective, admitting that MLS missed an opportunity to better prepare fans. While overall contributions to the league remain highly valued, the All-Star incident highlights the balancing act between athlete well-being and fan expectations.

As MLS continues to grow and attract global talent, the lessons from this event could help shape the league’s future making sure fans are not left guessing, and stars like Messi are better integrated into league culture.

For now, both Garber and have their eyes set on the remainder of the 2025 season where results on the field will matter more than any exhibition game.

Read more – Game-Changer: Shahnaz Yari’s Bold Mission to Empower Iranian Girls Through Football