When the Republican-backed tax reform bill passed under Donald Trump’s presidency, it sparked both celebration and criticism across the country. The bill, officially known as the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, was the biggest tax overhaul in decades. It promised to reduce corporate taxes, offer temporary cuts for individuals, and simplify the tax code.
But how did this major legislative victory affect the public’s opinion of President Trump? In this article, we break down Trump’s approval rating after the tax bill passed, using major national polls, expert commentary, and historical comparisons.
Trump’s Approval Rating After Tax Bill: Initial Boost or Continued Struggle?
Despite the administration touting the tax reform as a win for the American people, Trump’s approval rating after the tax bill didn’t soar as much as some expected. According to several major polling organizations, there was only a modest increase in public support immediately after the bill passed.
Gallup Poll: Slight Uptick
Gallup, which tracks weekly presidential approval ratings, showed a small increase from 35% to 37% in the week following the bill’s passage. While the 2-point rise was a welcome sign for the White House, it still meant that more than 60% of Americans disapproved of Trump’s overall performance.
Quinnipiac University Poll: Mixed Reaction
The Quinnipiac poll released shortly after the bill passed revealed a disapproval rate of 55%, with only 36% approving of Trump. Interestingly, the poll found that while some Republicans became more supportive, many independents and Democrats remained skeptical of the tax reform’s long-term benefits.
CNN Poll: Partisan Divide Still Strong
CNN’s polling showed that 51% of Americans disapproved of the tax bill itself, and Trump’s overall job approval stood at 39%. The data highlighted a key trend: the bill had not significantly swayed public opinion, especially among those who were already critical of the president.
What’s in the Tax Bill? Why It Mattered Politically
To understand the impact on Trump’s approval rating after the tax bill, it’s important to look at the contents of the bill itself.
Key Highlights of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act:
- Corporate tax rate reduced from 35% to 21%
- Individual tax cuts applied, but set to expire after 2025
- Standard deduction doubled for individuals and families
- Child tax credit increased
- Limits placed on state and local tax (SALT) deductions
- Fewer people required to pay the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)
For many conservative voters and business leaders, this bill was a clear win. It fulfilled a major campaign promise and was seen as a legislative accomplishment in a year full of political setbacks.
However, critics argued that the bill overwhelmingly favored corporations and the wealthy, while middle-class benefits were limited and temporary. These concerns may have played a major role in the lukewarm public response.
Expert Analysis: Why the Bump Wasn’t Bigger
1. Polarization at an All-Time High
Political scientists agree that Trump’s presidency is one of the most polarizing in U.S. history. According to Pew Research, party loyalty heavily influences how Americans perceive presidential actions. So, even a major legislative win like the tax bill couldn’t bridge that divide.
“Most Americans have already made up their minds about Trump, and they’re not easily moved by individual policy wins,” said Dr. Lauren Watson, a political analyst at Georgetown University.
2. Lack of Public Understanding
Another reason for the limited boost in Trump’s approval rating after the tax bill may be the public’s confusion about the bill’s contents. Several surveys found that a significant portion of Americans didn’t understand how the bill would affect them personally.
This lack of clarity allowed misinformation and skepticism to spread, especially among working-class voters who weren’t sure whether they’d benefit or not.
3. Timing and Media Coverage
The tax bill passed in late December, a time when many people are focused on the holidays. News coverage was also split between other controversial topics like immigration and the Russia investigation. As a result, the bill didn’t dominate headlines for long enough to shift public opinion significantly.
Historical Comparison: How Did Other Presidents Fare?
Looking back at other presidents who passed major tax legislation provides useful context.
- Ronald Reagan’s Tax Reform Act of 1986 gave him a temporary popularity boost, but it didn’t fundamentally change his approval ratings long-term.
- George W. Bush’s tax cuts in 2001 came during a post-9/11 surge in national unity, helping him reach record approval levels.
- Barack Obama’s 2009 stimulus bill, which included tax cuts, faced similar skepticism to Trump’s bill, with little change in his popularity at the time.
This pattern suggests that tax reforms, even if historic, rarely result in significant or lasting shifts in presidential approval—especially in divided political climates.
Did the Economy Help Trump’s Ratings?
Around the time the tax bill passed, the U.S. economy was strong. The stock market was climbing, unemployment was dropping, and consumer confidence was high. Trump frequently pointed to these economic indicators as proof of his success.
However, the polls showed that many Americans didn’t directly credit Trump for the good economy. A CBS News poll found that only 31% said the tax bill would help them financially, while 43% believed it would help the wealthy the most.
This mismatch between economic growth and personal benefit perception meant that Trump’s approval rating after the tax bill stayed relatively flat.
Breakdown by Demographics
Republican Voters
- Over 80% supported Trump and viewed the tax bill positively.
- Considered it a promise kept and a sign of effective leadership.
Independent Voters
- Mixed responses, with many unsure how it would affect them.
- Concerns about the national deficit and inequality were high.
Democratic Voters
- Overwhelmingly opposed to both Trump and the tax bill.
- Believed it was a giveaway to corporations and the wealthy elite.
This polarization meant that any potential gains in approval were largely confined to Trump’s existing base.
What the Approval Rating Means Going Forward
As of the months following the bill’s passage, Trump’s approval rating remained in the mid-to-high 30s, with some variation depending on current events. The tax bill didn’t hurt his numbers, but it also didn’t give him the strong upward momentum that many Republicans had hoped for.
Political strategists believe that the true impact of the bill may be seen in upcoming elections, as taxpayers file returns and either see real benefits or not. The perception of fairness, not just the numbers, will likely shape future public opinion.
Final Thoughts
The passage of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act was undeniably a major legislative win for Donald Trump and the Republican Party. It was touted as a historic step toward economic reform, job growth, and a simplified tax system. But when it comes to public perception, the results were more muted.
Trump’s approval rating after the tax bill shows us an important lesson in American politics: policy wins don’t always translate to popularity wins. In a deeply divided nation, even big accomplishments are filtered through the lens of partisan beliefs.
As the country moves forward and voters reflect on how the tax changes affect their wallets, the legacy of this bill—and its impact on Trump’s standing—will become clearer.
Read Next – Trump Liberia English Comment: “Such Good English” Sparks Backlash
